Haymitch Is a HeroHaymitch is a hero. He courageously never succumbed to the lure of the Games—to become a killer, to scrounge for life at the cost of principle and morality. In doing so, he thwarted the Capitol’s agenda to show the districts that they are no different from them. That it’s just survival of the fittest—and the Capitol happens to be stronger for now.This is the kind of courage the Jewish people showed during the Holocaust. My Rebbe used to say that Hitler wanted to reduce people to animals—strip them of their dignity by forcing them to scrap for food and disregard their humanity. But, as the vast Holocaust anthology of biographical and historical record shows, they continued to keep the Torah and mitzvos, and treated each other with kindness and altruism, even in the darkest conditions.President Snow is disproportionately disquieted by Haymitch’s defiance because he understands this is the seed of a true rebellion: the idea that one can make a statement—to oneself and to others—that they are not evil. That there is good in the world, and it’s worth the sacrifice.Haymitch had a different agenda: to destroy the evil—not those who were duped by that evil into playing its game.One of the clearest ways he showed this was by refusing to be bullied or blackmailed, even when Snow threatened to kill his family. It is not his fault that his family died—Snow is responsible. Had Haymitch given in, he would have become a shell of himself—a puppet, a kind of whore dancing to the Capitol’s will.The fact that he blames himself for their deaths is belied by his actions: he continues on his mission.His depression doesn’t come from failure, but from his predicament. As Victor Frankel in Man’s Search for Meaning asserts, in the midst of destruction, one still needs to be a hero. Evil can control your circumstances, but not your reaction to them.Even Yirmiyahu, who followed God’s command to the point of extreme danger to himself, wished that he was never born (Yirmiyahu 15:10)—not because he failed, but because of the crushing weight of his situation.Lenore Dove’s character wasn’t fully developed, making it hard to relate to her or be deeply affected by her death. However, the author connects her to Lucy Gray—buried in the same place—hinting that President Snow’s relationship with Haymitch may run far deeper than revealed.Even though Maysilee had a platonic relationship with Haymitch, their bond was transformative. Her character served as a tautological anchor for him—a living reminder of his resistance and values. Through her deeds, actions, formality, and presentation, she taught him that one can resist manipulation and avoid devolving into savagery. She modeled dignity, kindness, courage, and strength—even in her final breath. She wraps her pinky around his to remind him of their mission: to bring down the Capitol, even if it seems impossible.Lucy Gray seals this aspiration in her dying moment, pointing at the sun and telling Haymitch not to let it rise on the Reaping. Hence, the title of the book.In my opinion, the author’s intention is to give the reader insight into why Haymitch becomes an alcoholic. He is trapped in depression.Snow’s evil machinations have plunged him into a world of immense suffering, with all his family and loved ones lost. He refuses to take his own life because, deep down, he knows that would give Snow the ultimate victory. But at the same time, he doesn’t want to live. So, he escapes—until he is ultimately released by Katniss Everdeen in The Hunger Games.I know this is a stylistic issue, but it would’ve been fascinating to see more from the Capitol’s and Snow’s perspectives. Clearly, this mini-rebellion caused major disruption, and it’s unclear how much damage control had to be done to smooth out the propaganda.
)
Shop All Audiobooks
