Customer Reviews
This is a masterfully written book. I agree with some of the other reviewers who argue that the story itself is suspect at points -- though I'm inclined to believe the author, as I've known a few people that border on his type of crazy. Put aside plausibility of the plot, however, and you'll be rewarded by an audacious and powerful work. Time will tell if Frey's book falls into the company of Morrison, Faulkner, Joyce, DeLillo, et al. Until such judgment is passed, however, know that this book is certainly a contender for their company, and should be read by anyone who loves language and loves challenges to rhetorical convention.2008 - Very Late Addendum:Obviously, Frey's been debunked as just so much a mythmaker. Unfortunately, his stupid claim that the story is "true" has overshadowed what is nonetheless still a great book. No one will probably ever know what prompted the author to lie as he did. He can still write, though. From a literary standpoint, the question is whether this story will pack the punch it once did given the controversy around it. Truly a shame.
Update:Now that we know this guy's a big liar, I wouldn't recommend this at all.First review:James Frey's debut is really something special. His writing is stark and simple, yet completely descriptive and powerful. I really could not put this book down and recommend it completely.This was an absolute bonus. I purchased this book (and his second, My Friend Leonard) after seeing Frey on John Stossel's Addiction program. Frey stood by his belief that addicts make a choice to drink. Yes, it's a compulsion, maybe, and there may very well be a physical component. However, he believes that he and only he is responsible for his addiction. Not a higher power. And, I admire this about him and immediately ordered his book.Because he survives, it is easy to see much of what he goes through at the treatment center with a bit of dark humor. He, too, sees the lunacy in his situation and with the people he meets. Although he mentions a few of the less colorful characters, he really hangs around the hardcore addicts. And, seeing what happens to all of these folks at the end is more than a little heartbreaking.I've been reading a lot of addiction memoirs recently, and this is one of the best. If you're thinking of purchasing this, get his follow-up memoir, too, My Friend Leonard.
Beautifully and tragically written. The attention to detail is amazing. Read it 3 times so far. I love Leonard so much!
The book cover arrived damaged.
I enjoyed this book, a lot. It’s gritty, raw, and accurate. True or based on true is irrelevant. The story is relevant. Strong characters. Just my opinion, obvs.
